So I was watching X-men for the sixth or seventh time a few nights ago, while my wife was hanging out with her chick friends in the other room. And I may not be the world’s biggest X-men expert. OK, I am definitely not the world’s biggest X-men expert.
But how about Wolverine’s claws? Where do they go when they retract? If they only go back right beneath his knuckles then there’s no way he could bend his wrists. He would be Stiff-Wrist Logan, the Canadian Mystery Guy. Think about all the things you couldn’t do with adamantium wrists. Like play the fiddle or deal cards in a smooth and attractive manner, or chip. (As in golf.) Or hold out your hand in the universal gesture for “stop”. He would just be giving the sign for “I punch you in the face” or “I poke you in the throat”, which would make directing traffic awkward and give him a bad reputation. Come to think of it, how would he arrange his hair in that swirly horn pattern without some repeated circular wrist action and a lot of product?
Or if they retract all the way into his forearms, he has to make sure his wrists are straight when he extends them or they would poke through the wrong spot in his hands. Even with instant healing powers that would get annoying over time.
And cyclops. OK, what’s the advantage of having laser eye beams if you have to use your hand to make it fire? That’s like just carrying around a laser gun, which any storm trooper or GI Joe cartoon character can replicate. Or it’s more like a laser gun that is attached to your face all the time. Gunhead McGee is what they’d call you in school, and you couldn’t do anything about it because if anyone ended up with a laser hole in their chest, you know who they’d blame every time.
And why doesn’t Rogue steal her own powers when she touches herself? And why are Storm and the frog tongue guy just all-around lame?
Don’t get me wrong; I believe we could all use some gratuitous genetic mutation that would bestow amazing powers or double jointed-ness in our knees and elbows, or the instinctive mastery of the semi-colon. I just think the creators could think through the implications of some of the mutants they invent.
For example, you could invent a guy named Plastic-Face Alan. His face looks regular, but it’s genetically really plastic. So in addition to being able to change his face into whatever he wants it to look like, he could also absorb any face-punch ever, and trap your fist in liquid face-plastic. That’s a double payoff for a single mutation, which is exactly the kind of thing we need to be working towards here.



